Proctor Silex 2-Slice Toaster Review — Budget Wide-Slot Toaster

Intro

If you want a no-nonsense two-slice toaster with wide slots and a few convenience buttons, the Proctor Silex Plastic 2 Slice Toaster (model 22660) is squarely aimed at value-minded home cooks. The listing positions it as a compact, feature-focused counter appliance: bagel, defrost and cancel buttons, seven shade settings, a high-lift carriage and a slide-out crumb tray. It’s listed as a plastic-bodied toaster, weighs 2.5 pounds, runs at 700 watts on 120V, and comes in at least two colorways (Oat White and Red).

What it is / first look

At first glance this is a straightforward 2-slice, wide-slot toaster designed for everyday breakfast tasks. The key features called out by the listing are:

• Two wide slots intended for thick-sliced bread and bagels (listed as "wide slots").
• Bagel, Defrost and Cancel buttons (the listing describes three programs and shows illuminated bagel button behavior).
• Seven shade/browning settings via a shade selector.
• High-lift carriage (called "Toast Boost") to help retrieve smaller items.
• Slide-out crumb tray for cleaning.
• 700 watts operating power and a body described as plastic.

The toaster’s footprint and listed dimensions are 10.4" deep x 6.7" wide x 7" high and a listed weight of 2.5 pounds — small and light enough for limited counter space or an apartment kitchen. The listing describes a modern, matte finish and the manufacturer messaging highlights product testing in their engineering lab.

Colors

The listing and supplied images indicate two colorways. Available colors may include the following:

• Oat White
• Red

Note: several owners specifically commented that the actual color can differ from expectations — some buyers who ordered the Oat White option described it as closer to beige or grey. That’s an important practical note if you’re buying to match kitchen finishes.

In daily use

The Proctor Silex is built around simple, repeatable routines: toast bread, bagels and frozen items without complication. The listing emphasizes ease-of-use: a 7-setting shade selector means everyone can choose a preferred darkness, and the bagel and defrost buttons are intended to handle thicker or frozen items without fiddling with the lever mid-cycle.

Everyday breakfast

Owner feedback focuses on straightforward performance. Repeated praise points to even toasting for typical bread and muffins and the convenience of an illuminated bagel button. Several owners say the slots are generous enough for thicker slices and artisan-style bread. A common positive thread: this is a compact toaster that simply works for two people — suitable for households that want a reliable everyday toaster rather than a high-end appliance.

What owners liked

• Many owners describe the toaster as attractive and well-matched to kitchen decor, particularly the red finish when chosen.
• Several buyers praised the simple buttons (bagel, defrost, cancel) and the shade selector working as expected.
• Owners frequently note the Toast Boost/high-lift feature makes retrieving smaller items easier.
• Reviewers with smaller households liked the compact size and lightweight build — easy to tuck away or move around.

Real-world caveats

Owner feedback is not uniformly glowing. A few recurring issues show up in reviews and are worth calling out:

• Color mismatch: several owners ordered the Oat White option and received a toaster that looked beige or grey in their kitchens. Expect the listed color name to be an approximation.
• Crumb tray effectiveness: the listing includes a slide-out crumb tray, but multiple owners reported crumbs still ending up on the counter and having to wipe the area — the tray may not catch everything depending on how you load or remove bread.
• Uneven toasting: a handful of owners report uneven browning where the elements appear to light but one side is less toasted. Not everyone experienced this, but it’s a repeated theme in mixed reviews.
• Perceived long-term durability: some buyers called it a cheap toaster that may not last many years, while others contrasted positively with older Proctor Silex models that lasted decades. That creates mixed longevity expectations in buyer feedback.

Materials & build quality

The product listing lists the material as "Plastic" and gives the unit weight as 2.5 pounds. The exterior finish is described as matte and the style as modern. Beyond that, the listing focuses on features and testing rather than naming specific plastics or internal components.

What the listing states (directly):

• Material: Plastic.
• Finish Type: Matte.
• Item Dimensions: 10.4" D x 6.7" W x 7" H.
• Item Weight: 2.5 pounds.

Owners comment that the toaster is lightweight and compact. Several buyers explicitly call it a budget or inexpensive toaster, and a few say the overall construction feels inexpensive compared with heavier, metal-bodied models. On the positive side, multiple reviewers say it performs as expected for everyday toasting.

Safety considerations

The listing calls out several safety and convenience features: Automatic Shut-Off, a Cancel Function, and a High Lift Carriage (Toast Boost). The listing also highlights a slide-out crumb tray, which helps keep crumbs from building up under the heating elements.

Facts from the listing relevant to safety:

• Special Features listed: Automatic Shut-Off, Cancel Function, High Lift Carriage, Removable Crumb Tray, Variable Browning Control.
• Wattage: 700 watts; Voltage: 120.

How that translates to practical safety and everyday handling:

• Automatic Shut-Off and Cancel reduce the chance of overcooking or leaving the unit engaged indefinitely; those are standard features that help mitigate basic fire/overheat risk when used as intended.
• Toast Boost/high-lift carriage reduces the temptation to reach down into slots with fingers to retrieve small items.
• The slide-out crumb tray makes it easier to clear combustible crumbs from the cavity area — though owners say it doesn’t always catch every crumb, so periodic wiping of the surrounding counter and interior is still recommended.

Owner feedback doesn’t show a pattern of electrical or overheating failures in the available notes, but some users do describe inconsistent toasting which can lead to re-toasting cycles. Repeatedly re-toasting very dark or burnt slices is not good practice and will stress any toaster over time. As with any countertop appliance, follow the manufacturer instructions and your home electrical guidelines.

Who this is for / who should skip

This toaster is targeted at cooks who want a compact, budget-friendly, no-frills 2-slice toaster with a few handy programs. It’s especially well-suited to:

• Small households or two-person kitchens where counter space is limited.
• Buyers who want wide slots for bagels, thick slices, artisan bread, English muffins and waffles (the listing describes the slots as wide and the bread guides as holding slices centered).
• Shoppers who want simple controls — a 7-setting dial plus bagel, defrost and cancel buttons.

Who should skip

• If you want a heavy-duty, commercial-feel toaster or a metal-bodied appliance designed for heavy daily use, this plastic-bodied, lightweight model may feel too basic.
• If exact color matching is critical for your kitchen, be cautious: owners report the Oat White option can appear beige/grey in person compared with expectations.
• If you need perfect, professional-grade evenness for every loaf, some owner reports of uneven browning suggest you might prefer a higher-end model with stronger heating-element engineering.

Verdict

The Proctor Silex 2-slice toaster (model 22660) is a well-specified budget toaster on paper — wide slots, bagel and defrost buttons, Toast Boost high-lift carriage, a slide-out crumb tray and seven browning settings. For someone furnishing a small apartment or a two-person household, it hits the key practical notes: compact footprint, simple controls and a modern matte look in at least two colors (Oat White and Red).

Owner feedback leans positive for everyday use: many owners say it toasts evenly and appreciate the bagel/defrost functionality and the illuminated bagel button. But mixed reviews cluster around three practical issues: (1) the listed color can differ from the delivered finish; (2) the crumb tray may not catch every stray crumb, requiring occasional countertop cleanup; and (3) a minority of owners report uneven toasting. Durability expectations are mixed — some buyers describe it as "cheap but functional," while others compared it favorably to older Proctor Silex models they owned for years.

Check before you buy

• Confirm the color: owners report the Oat White option can look beige or grey in person.
• Expect a plastic-bodied, lightweight unit (Material: Plastic; Item Weight: 2.5 pounds).
• Confirm the features you need are present: the listing lists Bagel, Defrost and Cancel buttons plus a 7-position shade selector and a slide-out crumb tray.
• Consider how heavily you’ll use it — buyers wanting heavy daily use or long-term durability may prefer a metal-bodied, higher-end model.
• Note basic electrical specs: 700 watts on 120 V — suitable for standard household outlets (the listing provides wattage and voltage).

Overall: a solid budget pick for small kitchens and casual toasting needs, with a few real-world quirks reported by owners. If you want an inexpensive, compact toaster that covers bagels and frozen items, this fits the bill — but don’t expect premium build materials or absolute perfection in color or long-term durability.