Tops Fitz-All Percolator Top Review

Intro

If you've got a favorite percolator with a broken sight button or glass top, the Tops Fitz-All Replacement Percolator Top is a cheap, simple part that aims to get the pot back in service. The listing describes a small glass insert with a metal retaining ring sold as a 2-pack and intended for both electric and stovetop percolators. This review walks through what the part is, how it behaves in everyday use according to owner reports, build details the listing provides, safety considerations that matter for a glass component on a hot pot, and who should buy it — or skip it.

What it is / first look

On paper this is straightforward: the Tops Fitz-All (model 135) is a small glass percolator top described by the listing as ‘‘Fitz-All Brand small glass insert for metal percolator lids’’ and sold in a 2-pack. The listing lists the material type as "Glass, Metal," and gives the fit range for lid openings as 13/16 inch to 1-1/2 inch. The listing also calls out that the part "fits electric & stovetop percolators with cover openings" in that range and that it "fits tight, won't fall out."

The component itself is a clear glass cone or button that fits into the hole of a percolator lid, held in place by a metal ring that threads or clamps to the glass. Image filenames associated with the listing point to a clear-glass look with a metal retention ring; owners likewise describe and show a clear glass insert, so color choices are essentially clear glass with the metal ring.

In daily use

Owners provide the most useful sense of how this simple part performs when it matters: in the field, on the stovetop, or at camp. The pattern in owner feedback is overwhelmingly positive for practical use: people bought it because their original sight button had cracked, melted, or broken, and several report the Fitz-All restored otherwise serviceable percolators to working condition.

Stovetop & campfire use

The listing explicitly states compatibility with stovetop percolators, and owner reports back that the part works well on camp-style and stovetop pots. Multiple owners say they used the Fitz-All on Coleman and other stainless-steel percolators, and one owner specifically reported leaving a percolator on a fire and cooking it dry for hours without the glass top breaking. That kind of anecdote suggests the piece can hold up in rougher, high-heat situations — though owner reports are not a substitute for lab testing.

Electric percolators

The listing also lists electric percolators as compatible. Owners who replaced broken plastic or melted buttons on electric units report the Fitz-All fit snugly and stayed in place when properly installed. Several people describe twisting the metal washer or screw ring to secure the insert so it "fits tight" and "won't fall out," matching the listing's claim.

Camping, vintage pots, and unusual models

A recurring theme in owner notes is that this piece often fits percolators for which original parts are no longer sold. Buyers report successful fits on vintage Cory percolators, Ozark Trail 12-cup pots, Elite Gourmet, and even older Coleman models. That makes this a useful rescue part if you want to keep an older or favorite pot in service rather than discarding it.

What to expect from fit and installation

The listing gives a clear numeric fit range: it is intended for cover openings between 13/16" and 1-1/2". Buyers describe a twisting-on action to tighten the metal retention ring against the lid; pictures and notes in owner comments show users twisting the ring to secure the glass top so it "stays on tight." If you have a percolator lid hole in the recommended range, expect to install the glass insert and then secure it with the metal ring as described by multiple owners.

Materials & build quality

The listing lists "Glass, Metal" as the material types and positions the product as a small glass insert with a metal retaining piece. That combination is the clearest factual material description available. Owners repeatedly comment on the advantage of glass over the cheap plastic sight buttons that often come with low-cost percolators. Comments use phrases like "it is glass," "easy to wash," and "seem thick and durable."

Several owners explicitly call the replacement glass "stronger than the original lid on many coffee percs." One owner who used it on a Coleman pot said the percolator "cleaned up almost like new and the glass top ... didn't break" after being cooked dry for hours. Another owner described the part as "very durable" and praised the value of getting two in a pack.

There is one recurring design complaint worth noting: a handful of owners observed that the threaded stem on the inside of some percolator lids can be short, and that prevents adding an extra rubber gasket between the stem and the metal ring. One owner described the metal ring as hollow and said liquid can get trapped inside the hollow ring; they noted a small hole in the ring to release some water but still reported some trapped liquid. That same owner tried adding a rubber gasket but found the threaded stem too short to accommodate it on their Elite Gourmet percolator. So while build quality of the glass and ring is praised by many, the assembly interface with particular percolator lid designs is where a mismatch can surface.

Safety considerations

Two facts anchor safety for this product: the listing describes the part as glass with a metal ring, and owners report using it on both stovetop and electric percolators. From that combined information, follow these safety-minded points before and during use:

• Verify the hole size: the listing specifies it fits cover openings from 13/16" to 1-1/2". A correct fit minimizes wobble and the chance of glass chipping. Several buyers emphasize the importance of a snug installation; the listing itself says it "fits tight, won't fall out."
• Check for trapped liquid in the ring: some owners report that the metal ring is hollow and can trap liquid between the ring and the stem. The listing acknowledges the metal component but does not describe an internal gasket. Owner feedback notes a small hole in the metal ring to release water, but that some trapped liquid can remain. If your lid design leaves liquid trapped, dry the ring and inspect it regularly for corrosion or residue.
• Watch for chips and cracks: while multiple owners report surprisingly good durability — including surviving a dry cook-on incident — glass is still a brittle material. The listing does not quantify thermal shock resistance or any temperature limits. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and monitor the glass top for chips or cracks; replace it if you see damage. (The listing does not specify maximum temperature or thermal limits.)
• Installation security: the listing claims a tight fit and owners back that up when the metal ring is properly tightened. A loose or poorly seated insert is a hazard during pouring or when lifting the lid, so be sure the ring is secure and the glass sits flush before use.

Who this is for / who should skip

This product is for the home cook or camper who already owns a percolator and needs a replacement sight/top — especially for older or discontinued models where OEM parts are no longer available. The owner feedback shows it can resurrect otherwise-functioning pots, saving money and waste. Specific buyer profiles that align with the listing and owner reports:

• Owners of stovetop or electric percolators with a broken or missing glass top who can measure their lid hole and confirm it falls between 13/16" and 1-1/2".
• People with vintage or less-common percolator models (examples in owner notes include Cory, Ozark Trail 12-cup, Elite Gourmet, Coleman) who want a universal-fit replacement rather than replacing the entire pot.
• Campers and outdoors cooks who use percolators over open flame or camp stoves — owners report successful use in camp settings and strong durability in at least one anecdote involving prolonged dry cooking.

Who should skip or be cautious:

• If your lid hole falls outside the listed 13/16"–1-1/2" range, the part will likely not seat correctly — the listing gives that fit range explicitly, so measure first.
• If your lid design depends on a rubber gasket between the glass and the lid stem, be cautious: owner feedback indicates the threaded stem on some lids is too short to accept an added gasket, and the listing does not mention including any gasket. One buyer tried to add a gasket but could not get it to work with the shorter stem on their model.
• If you need dishwasher-safe confirmation or manufacturer temperature specs, the listing does not specify those details; the listing text and owner reports reference washability and durability but do not provide formal dishwasher or thermal ratings.

Verdict

For a small, inexpensive replacement part, the Tops Fitz-All Replacement Percolator Top delivers exactly what most buyers are looking for: a clear glass top with a metal retention ring that, within the listed fit range, restores the sight-button function of electric and stovetop percolators. Owners repeatedly report it saves otherwise good pots, fits snugly when installed, is easy to clean, and holds up well — with multiple notes praising durability and one detailed account of the glass top surviving a percolator being cooked dry.

The main practical caveat is interface details: a hollow metal ring that can trap liquid and an internal threaded stem on some percolators that may be too short to accept an added gasket. Those are not universal issues, but they show up enough in owner feedback to be worth checking for your own pot before relying on the replacement long-term.

Check before you buy

• Measure your percolator lid opening — the listing specifies compatibility with openings between 13/16" and 1-1/2".
• Note the package is sold as a 2-pack (the listing lists number of pieces as 2), so you receive two tops in the shipment.
• If your lid normally uses a rubber gasket or a long internal stem, check the stem length; owner reports indicate a short stem can prevent adding a gasket.
• Inspect the metal ring after installation for any trapped liquid; owner feedback notes the ring is hollow and may collect water even though it usually has a small drain hole.
• Verify the part fits your exact model by comparing with owner-reported fits — buyers have had success with Cory, Ozark Trail, Elite Gourmet, and Coleman percolators — but confirm measurements first.
• Follow manufacturer or listing instructions for installation and care; the listing does not provide dishwasher or thermal specifications, so when in doubt hand-wash and inspect for chips before use.

Overall: a budget-friendly, practical replacement that solves a common failure point on inexpensive percolators. The combination of glass and metal gives it an advantage over broken plastic sight buttons, and owner reports suggest it can be surprisingly durable. Just confirm the hole size and check how the metal ring interfaces with your lid before you rely on it for daily use.

FAQ

1. What lid opening sizes does this fit?

   The listing specifies it fits percolator cover openings from 13/16" to 1-1/2". Measure your lid hole to confirm it falls in that range before buying.

2. Is the top glass or plastic?

   The listing lists the material as "Glass, Metal," and multiple owners explicitly call it glass in their feedback.

3. How many pieces are in the package?

   The listing shows this is sold as a 2-pack; the specifications list the number of pieces as 2 and the package size name as "2 pack."

4. Will it fit my Elite Gourmet / Coleman / Ozark Trail percolator?

   Owner feedback reports successful fits on a range of brands including Ozark Trail (12-cup), Elite Gourmet, Cory, and Coleman stainless-steel percolators. That indicates the product often works across models, but you should still check your lid opening dimensions and the way your lid secures the glass before assuming compatibility.

5. Is there a gasket included or recommended?

   The listing does not specify a gasket. Owners report the metal ring is hollow and some tried adding a rubber gasket, but one buyer said the threaded stem on their percolator was too short to accept an added gasket. The listing does not list a gasket as part of the product.

6. Can I use this on a campfire or open flame percolator?

   The listing states it fits stovetop percolators, and owner reports include successful use on camp-style pots and a report of the glass top surviving a prolonged dry-cook incident. That suggests it can be used in high-heat camping situations, but monitor it and follow safe use practices; the listing does not provide formal thermal ratings.

7. Is it dishwasher-safe?

   The listing doesn't specify whether it is dishwasher-safe. Owners say it is easy to wash, but for dishwasher confirmation you need to consult the current manufacturer/listing details.

8. What model number is this?

   The listing identifies the part as model number 135 from the Tops Fitz-All line and lists Fox Run Craftsmen as the manufacturer.